Abstract
Jun 24
Back

AUTONOMOUS VEHICLE AND THE LIMITS OF TRADITIONAL LIABILITY: BETWEEN LEGAL DOCTRINE AND TECHNOLOGICAL INNOVATION

Ranko SOVILJ

[Institute of Social Sciences, Belgrade, Serbia]

Sanja ZLATANOVIĆ

[Institute of Social Sciences, Belgrade, Serbia]
10.51204/Anali_PFBU_26201A
ABSTRACT /

The paper examines legal liability for damages caused by autonomous vehicles by analyzing the legal and technical characteristics of highly automated and fully autonomous driving systems, as well as the relevant international, regional, and national legal frameworks. While existing motor vehicle insurance and product liability regimes provide an important foundation, they remain fragmented and insufficiently adapted to the technological and normative complexities of autonomous mobility. The paper demonstrates that traditional driver-based liability models are structurally misaligned with highly automated driving, creating systemic gaps in the allocation of liability. Adopting a doctrinal and comparative approach, it highlights the need for a coherent, flexible, and forward-looking regulatory framework capable of reconciling technological innovation with legal accountability. The findings contribute to the ongoing scholarly and policy debates on the future design of liability regimes for autonomous vehicles.

DOWNLOAD COMPLETE ARTICLE /
English  
REFERENCES /
  1. ADAS. 2024. SAE Level 2 – Partial Driving Automation. April 2024. https://www.aaa-adas.us/sae/level-two, last visited May 28, 2026.
  2. Anderson, James M., Nidhi Kalra, Karlyn D. Stanley, Paul Sorensen, Constantine Samaras, Oluwatobi A. Oluwatola. 2016. Autonomous Vehicle Technology – A Guide for Policymakers. Santa Monica: RAND Corporation.
  3. Ba, Zhuo, Ziyu Zhao, Bokang Zhang. 12/2025. Liability for Autonomous Vehicle Torts: Who Should Be Held Responsible? World Electric Vehicle Journal 16: 1–21.
  4. Belanić, Loris, Eric Milisavljević. 2023. Autonomna vozila i odgovornost za štetu [Autonomous vehicle and liability for damages]. Hrvatski časopis za osiguranje 8: 11–31.
  5. Butilă, Eugen Valentin, Gheorghe-Daniel Voinea, Răzvan Gabriel Boboc, Grigore Ambrosi. 2/2026. Autonomous Vehicles in the Traffic Ecosystem: A Comprehensive Review of Integration, Impacts, and Policy Implications. Vehicles 41: 1–37.
  6. Chatzipanagiotis, Michael, George Leloudas. 1/2020. Automated Vehicles and Third-Party Liability: A European Perspective. Journal of Law, Technology & Policy 2020: 109–199.
  7. De Bruyne, Jan, Jarich Werbrouck. 5/2018. Merging Self-Driving Cars with the Law. Computer Law & Security Review 34: 1150–1153.
  8. Doskoch, Julia. 2023. “Your Honor, the Car Crashed Itself”: Navigating Autonomous Vehicles Liability in an Age of Innovation. Boston College Intellectual Property & Technology Forum Journal 2023: 1–13.
  9. Dumančić, Kosjenka, Dominik Vuletić. 2025. Liability for Damages Caused by Autonomous Driving Vehicles from the EU Law Perspective. EU and Comparative Law Issues and Challenges Series (ECLIC) 9: 64–76.
  10. Duncan, Ian, Lina Bonos. 2026. Waymo robotaxi hits child at school drop-off, triggering safety inquiry. The Washington Post, January 29.
  11. Ebers, Martin. 2022. Civil Liability for Autonomous Vehicles in Germany. https://ssrn.com/abstract=4027594, last visited May 28, 2026.
  12. Fernandez-Llorca David. 2021. From driving automation systems to autonomous vehicles: clarifying the terminology. arXiv preprint arXiv 2103.10844.
  13. Frisman, Paul. 2012. California’s Self-Driving Vehicle Law. OLR Research Report 2012-R-0456. October 16. https://www.cga.ct.gov/2012/rpt/pdf/2012-R-0456.PDF, last visited May 28, 2026.
  14. Garthwaite, Josie. 2012. Google Gets First Driverless Car License: Strings Attached. National Geographic. May 9. https://www.nationalgeographic.com/environment/article/google-gets-first-driverless-car-license-strings-attached, last visited May 28, 2026.
  15. Gurney, K. Jeffrey. 2/2013. Sue My Car Not Me: Products Liability and Accidents Involving Autonomous Vehicles. Journal of Law, Technology & Policy 2013: 247–277.
  16. Hacker, Philipp. 2023. The European AI Liability Directives – Critique of a Half-Hearted Approach and Lessons for the Future. Computer Law & Security Review 51: 1–42.
  17. Janković, Svetislav, Ranko Sovilj, Sanja Zlatanović. 1/2025. Društveni i pravni položaj vozača-migranata u javnom drumskom saobraćaju. Stanovništvo 63: 73–92.
  18. Jones Day. 2021. Autonomous Vehicles: Legal and Regulatory Developments in the United States. White paper. Jones Day. May. https://www.jonesday.com/-/media/files/publications/2021/05/autonomous-vehicles-legal-and-regulatory-developments-in-the-us/files/autonomous-vehicles-legal-and-regulatory-developme/fileattachment/autonomous-vehicles-legal-and-regulatory-developm.pdf, last visited May 28, 2026.
  19. Kajtez, Miloš N. 2014. Autonomna vozila: početak i primena robotizovanih vozila u saobraćaju (Autonomous Vehicles: The Beginning and the Application of Robotic Vehicles in Traffic). eRAF Journal on Computing 6: 15–35.
  20. Karanikić Mirić, Marija. 2016. Prilog razumevanju pravila o solidarnoj odgovornosti imalaca motornih vozila (čl. 178 st. 4 ZOO) (Joint and Several Liability of the Proprietors of Motor Vehicles in Road and Traffic Accidents). 188–201 in Perspektive implementacije evropskih standarda u pravni sistem Srbije (Perspectives of the Implementation of European Standards in the Legal System of Serbia), edited by Stevan Lilić. Belgrade: Pravni fakultet Univerziteta u Beogradu.
  21. Karanikić Mirić, Marija. 2017. General Clause on Strict Liability in Comparative Perspective. 345–356 in Law and Transition, edited by Bojan Milisavljević, Tatjana Jevremović Petrović, Miloš Živković. Belgrade: Pravni fakultet Univerziteta u Beogradu.
  22. Karkafiris, Michael. 2017. Audi Details New A8’s AI Traffic Jam Pilot, First Level 3 Autonomous System on the Market. Carscoops. September 7. https://www.carscoops.com/2017/09/audi-details-new-a8s-ai-traffic-jam/, last visited May 28, 2026.
  23. Kolodny, Lora, 2025. Tesla must pay portion of $329 million in damages after fatal Autopilot crash, jury says. CNBC. August 1. https://www.cnbc.com/2025/08/01/tesla-must-pay-329-million-in-damages-in-fatal-autopilot-case.html, last visited May 28, 2026.
  24. Kordić, Biljana, Mira Rosić, Tanja Arsić, Dejan Milanović. 2017. Autonomna vozila i njihov uticaj na bezbednost saobraćaja (Autonomous Vehicles and Their Impact on Road Safety). 229–235 in Road Safety in Local Community: Conference Proceedings, edited by Krsto Lipovac, Dragan Jovanović, Miladin Nešić. Novi Sad: Faculty of Technical Sciences.
  25. Leiman, Tania. 2/2021. Law and tech collide: foreseeability, reasonableness and advanced driver assistance systems. Policy and Society 40: 250–271.
  26. Marchant, E. Gary, Rachel A. Lindor. 4/2012. The Coming Collision Between Autonomous Vehicles and the Liability System. Santa Clara Law Review 52: 1321–1340.
  27. Mehlhorn, Marcel Aguirre, Andreas Richter, Yuri A. W. Shardt. 2/2023. Ruling the Operational Boundaries: A Survey on Operational Design Domains of Autonomous Driving System. IFAC PapersOnLine 56: 2202–2213.
  28. Mendiboure, Leo, Mohamed Lamine Benzagouta, Dominique Gruyer, Tidiane Sylla, Morayo Adedjouma, Abdelmename Hedhli. 2023. Operational Design Domain for Automated Driving Systems: Taxonomy Definition and Application. Conference: 2023 IEEE Intelligent Vehicles Symposium IV: 1–6.
  29. Mercedes Benz. 2023. Certification for SAE Level 3 system for U.S. market. Mercedes Benz Group. January 26. https://group.mercedes-benz.com/technology/autonomous-driving/driving/drive-pilot-nevada.html, last visited May 28, 2026.
  30. Milenković, Melita, Davor Sumpor, Sandro Tokić. 1/2025. Legal and Safety Aspects of the Application of Automated and Autonomous Vehicles in the Republic of Croatia. World Electric Vehicle Journal 16: 34.
  31. Mrvić Petrović, Nataša. 2023. Odgovornost za štetu nastalu upotrebom automatizovanog vozila (Liability for Damage Caused by the Use of an Automated Vehicles). 29–50 in Prouzrokovanje štete, naknada štete i osiguranje (Causation of Damage, Damage Compensation and Insurance), edited by Zdravko Petrović, Vladimir Čolović, Dragan Obradović. Belgrade: Institut za uporedno pravo.
  32. Mudrić, Mihael. 2024. Automatizirana vozila i pravo – nered na cesti (2.). Bug.hr. February 13. https://www.bug.hr/automobili/automatizirana-vozila-i-pravo-nered-na-cesti-2–38352, last visited May 28, 2026.
  33. Murphy, Robin R. 2000. Introduction to AI Robotics. Cambridge, Massachusetts: MIT Press.
  34. Pellegatta, Stefano. 2019. Autonomous Driving and Civil Liability: The Italian Perspective. Rivista di Diritto Dell’ Economia, dei Transporti e dell’ Ambiente 17: 135–163.
  35. Radišić, Jakov. 1976. Imovinska odgovornost za štetu izazvanu motornim vozilom (Civil liability for damage caused by a motor vehicle). Belgrade: Institut društvenih nauka – Centar za pravna istraživanja.
  36. Razdan, Rahul, Raivo Sell, M. Ilhan Akbas, Mahesh Menase. 22/2025. Perspectives on Safety for Autonomous Vehicles. Electronics 14: 4500.
  37. Sovilj, Ranko. 2024. Odgovornost za štetu nastalu upotrebom autonomnih vozila (Liability for Damage Caused by the Use of Autonomous Vehicles). 38–43 in Knjiga sažetaka: Srbija i reformisanje instituta odgovornosti 7 (Book of summaries: Serbia and reforming the institute of liability 7), edited by Hajrija Mujović. Belgrade: Institut društvenih nauka; Novi Sad: Advokatska komora Vojvodine.
  38. Toman, Michal. 2023. AI Liability Directive – first impressions. 713–719 in Naděje právní vědy 2022. Pilsen: University of West Bohemia.
  39. UNECE. 2024. Guidelines and recommendations for Automated Driving System safety requirements, assessments and test methods to inform regulatory development. https://unece.org/sites/default/files/2024–11/ECE-TRANS-WP.29–2024–39e.pdf, last visited May 28, 2026.
  40. Uzair, Muhammad. 2/2021. Who Is Liable When a Driverless Car Crashes? World Electric Vehicle Journal 12: 62.
  41. Widen, H. William, Marilyn C. Wolf. 2025. Law as a Design Consideration for Automated Vehicles Suitable to Transport Intoxicated Persons. 1–7 in Proceedings of the 2025 Design, Automation & Test in Europe Conference (DATE), edited by Aida Todri-Sanial and Theo Theocharides. Lyon: IEEE.
  42. Yang, Yichuan, Zongyu Song. 1/2025. The public perception and adaptability of laws and regulations of autonomous driving vehicles. Humanities & Social Sciences Communications 12: 1–12.