Jelena Danilović
10.5937/AnaliPFB1702162D
This paper discusses employees’ right to privacy at work at the beginning of XXI century in Serbia and its relation to international regulations and practice. The right to privacy at work, in the context of this analysis, is considered as the right to protect employee’s personal data from employer’s improper intrusion. The first part of the paper provides overview of theories on privacy right as well as current data protection legal framework. This section shows that the concept of privacy changed significantly during the history and that development of data protection legislation, though intense, did not clarify some of the main ambiguities linked to this concept. Especially in Serbia, where data protection regulation is relatively new and practice rudimentary, there are many queries linked to the issue of privacy at work. The second part of the paper analyses in more details origins and importance of privacy legal standard established in the international practice – the „reasonable expectations of privacy“. Understanding of this legal standard and especially its influence to recent court practice of the European Court of Human Rights is important for comprehension of employee’s right to privacy. In-depth analysis shows that this standard includes an external element (privacy expected by the society) and internal element (privacy expected within the specific employer). While there are conceptual differences between the USA and European practice, the internal element of this legal standard in both cases has a major influence in the employment privacy disputes. Finally, the paper proposes that enacting of internal privacy policies, with full respect of data protection regulations, could provide for viable reasonable expectations of privacy at work. This may eventually lead to easier distinction of the fine line between employee’s privacy and employer’s interests.
- Article 29 Working Party, Working document on surveillance and monitoring of electronic communications in the workplace, http://ec.europa.eu/justice/policies/privacy/docs/wpdocs/2002/wp55_en.pdf, 23. mart 2017.
- Alexy, R., „Constitutional Rights and Proportionality“, Revus 22/2014.
- Brey, P., „The Importance of Workplace Privacy“, The Ethics of Workplace Privacy (eds. S. O. Hansson, E. Palm), Brisel 2005.
- De Schutter, O., „La protection du travailleur vis-à-vis des nouvelles technologies dans l’emploi“, Revue trimes-trielle des droits de l’homme 54/2003.
- Franeta, D., Ljudsko dostojanstvo kao pravna vrednost, Beograd 2015.
- Glensy, D. R., „The Right to Dignity“, Columbia Human Rights Law Review 43/2011.
- Jašarević, S., „Nove tendencije u oblasti zaštite ličnih podataka na radu u međunarodnom pravu“, Radno i socijalno pravo XX, 1/2016.
- Kovačević, Lj., Pravna subordinacija u radnom odnosu i njene granice, Beograd 2013.
- Kovačević, Lj., „Prikupljanje i korišćenje podataka o ličnosti kao radnopravni problem“, Socijalna prava i evropske integracije, zbornik radova sa Savetovanja pravnika (ur. B. Šunderić, B. Lubarda, P. Jovanović), Beograd 2011.
- Kovačević, Lj., „Radni odnos i pravo na poštovanje privatnog života“, Ostvarivanje i zaštita socijalnih prava, zbornik radova sa Savetovanja pravnika (ur. B. Šunderić, B. Lubarda, P. Jovanović), Beograd 2010.
- Levin, A., „Is There a Global Approach to Workplace Privacy?“, Surveillance, Privacy, and the Globalization of personal information: international comparisons (eds. E. Zureik, E. Smith, L. Harling Stalker, D. Lyon), Montreal 2010.
- Mantouvalou, V., „Life after Work: Privacy and Dismissal“, LSE Law, Society and Economy Working Papers 5/2008, 1–28.
- Marković, B. S., Ogled o odnosima između pojma pravde i razvitka pozitivnog privatnog prava, Beograd 1995.
- Morgan, C., „Employer Monitoring of Employee Electronic Mail and Internet Use“, McGill Law Journal 44/1999.
- Onn, Y. et al., Privacy in the Digital Environment, Haifa 2005.
- Pirc Musar, N., Vodič kroz Zakon o zaštiti podataka o ličnosti, Beograd 2009.
- Rustad, M. L., Paulsson S. R., „Monitoring Employee E-Mail and Internet Usage: Avoiding the Omniscient Electronic Sweatshop: Insights from Europe“, University of Pennsylvania Journal of Labor and Employment Law 7/2005.
- Solove, D. J., Understanding Privacy, Cambridge 2008.
- Šabić R., „I na poslu mora postojati ‘razumno očekivana privatnost’“, http://www.poverenik.rs/sr/saopstenja-i-aktuelnosti/ 1669-i-na-poslu-mora-postojati-razumno-ocekivana-privatnost.html, 23. mart 2017.
- Šabić R., „Pitanja i odgovori“, http://www.poverenik.rs/sr/pitanja-i-odgovori/1596-pitanja-i-odgovori.html, 23. mart 2017.
- Šabić, R., „Poligrafsko ispitivanje – nedozvoljena obrada ličnih podataka“, http://www.poverenik.rs/sr/saopstenja-i-aktuelnosti/2403-poligrafsko-ispitivanje-nedozvoljena-obrada-licnih-podataka.html, 23. mart 2017.
- Šabić, R., „Zašto nam treba novi zakon o zaštiti podataka o ličnosti“, http://www.poverenik.rs/sr/model-zakona-o-zastiti-podataka-o-licnosti.html, 1. februar 2017.
- Šabić, R., „Nov model zakona o zaštiti podataka o ličnosti“, http://www.poverenik.org.rs/sr/ saopstenja-i-aktuelnosti/2554-nov-model-zakona-o-zastiti-podataka-o-licnosti.html, 23. mart 2017.
- Thomson, J. J., „The Right to Privacy“, Philosophy and Public Affairs IV, 4/1975.
- Živković, B. „Pravo na privatnost zaposlenog i video nadzor“, Pravni informator 6/2015.
- Warren, S. D., Brandeis, L. D, „The Right to Privacy“, Harvard Law Review IV, 5/1890.
Comments are closed.